\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://mathguy.writing.com/main/authors.php/action/reviewers
The Writing.Com members below are accepting review requests and ready to review your item! Peruse the list, check out members' review styles and request a review from anyone who seems like a good fit for your item.
dragonfish's Portfolio
Preferred Author
Angelica Weatherby- July 4th Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I look for how well the story or poem flows and if there are things out of place. I also check for grammar and spelling errors.
sisterofmercy's Portfolio
Preferred Author
very thankful Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I used a template for all of my reviews. I will comment on plot, characters, scene/setting, grammar, and anything else that comes to mind.
leslieloo1's Portfolio
Registered Author
Leslie Loo Author Icon
(minimum 1,500 GPs)
I don't know what my style is, but I point out what sticks out at me.
Preferred Author
bob county Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I look at the fun factor.
xonereth's Portfolio
Registered Author
Xonereth Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
Im happy to review most things, if it holds my interest though I will be less sloppy and more engaged.
Registered Author
LorenIsOneOfMyNames Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I'm honest but constructive. I'll explain why I give the number of stars I give and what you could do to improve that. I do fix grammar as well as look at style, emotional triggers, characters, and other things like that. I'll get back to you with a full review in a couple of days or so after the request, depending on the length of the item.
tvelocity's Portfolio
Preferred Author
Graham B. Author Icon
(minimum 2,500 GPs)
Brutally honest, but fair. I will give my impressions of the main points: Plot, character, setting, dialog. Then I will get into grammar, spelling, and typos. I will tell you what works, and what doesn't. As far as the star ratings go, I don't rely on them too much, but use them as a measure of an item's relative merit. Take it for what it's worth. Bottom line, my goal is to help the author improve their work.
Registered Author
S.J - Not Around Much Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I'm honest when I review thing I'll say what's on my mind but at the same time I try to stay positive and will always tell you what you did right but this means in no way am I a professional reviewer so take my reviews with a grin of salt please
soledad_moon's Portfolio
Preferred Author
Stik to My Own Beat Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
In a single word, thorough. I will turn your piece upside down, shake the change out of its pockets and look at even the most minute details. I can be technical but will do so when emphasizing a larger point about the piece as a whole.
jim-d's Portfolio
Moderator
Sum1 Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
Casual for the most part. I will point out errors I see and offer suggested corrections. I like to focus on the content and formatting of the item. I love providing helpful comments and feedback that may improve the item if acted on.
Preferred Author
Indelible Ink Author Icon
(minimum 5,000 GPs)
I try to imagine I've just taken a seat in the waiting room at a doctor's office and picked up a magazine to pass the time. Suddenly - what's this? - I stumble upon your little work of art. As a result of reading your story, either I will 1) I like it so much I MUST have it, so I stuff the magazine down the front of my shirt and hope the doctor isn't checking my heartbeat today, or 2) Become so nauseated at the ineptitude displayed by your chicken scratches that I will beg the doctor to consider me for an emergency euthanasia. Chances are it will be somewhere in the middle.
Preferred Author
Mousethyme Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
Casual. More my opinion than, say, most reviewers.
belverk's Portfolio
Registered Author
von Garrett Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
In particular I can help with wording and flow issues. I give constructive feedback on the general feel, plot holes, and where you may need more or less detail in your work. My feedback is (sometimes brutally) honest, but is aimed at helping you improve your work. If I don't like your work I probably won't review it, so please take any criticism as a form of praise.
Preferred Author
Amethyst Angel 🌼 Author Icon
(minimum 2,000 GPs)
Casual, friendly. I'll point out typos when I see them and make suggestions about quality, characters and logic, besides telling you how I feel about the piece.
Registered Author
lucky dog Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I do my best to give an honest assessment of what I'm reading, I don't nit pick on spelling and grammar but will mention something that is glaring and should be pointed out.
Registered Author
Escape Artist Author Icon
(minimum 1,500 GPs)
My opinion will rely heavily on content, character and story arc, and reflect anything that catches my eye...purely from a readers standpoint.
Registered Author
Enthusiasm Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I dissect stories like a surgeon with a poet’s hands—probing the emotional marrow, not just the bones. My reviews prioritize thematic resonance, psychological authenticity, and prose that feels before it explains. I’ll ask why the rain in your story smells like regret, or how the silence between lovers becomes its own character. Technical critiques (pacing, grammar) come only if requested—I’m here to unravel why your story haunts, not just how it functions.
Preferred Author
LightinMind Author Icon
(minimum 2,000 GPs)
I try to be honest and positive. My Christian faith is an important background factor. I hate rating low but have a system that determines how I grade.
 
STATIC
My Philosophy of Rating and Reviewing Open in new Window. (E)
How do I assess people's work when reviewing?
#2259390 by LightinMind Author IconMail Icon
dyxe0ri's Portfolio
Registered Author
dyxe0ri Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I will organize it by first thoughts, then if the genre and rating is appropriate, what I liked, improvements, and my final opinion.
Preferred Author
WakeUpAndLive~Petra's Vacay Author Icon
(minimum 1,000 GPs)
I try to find the WOW-factor in your writing. No in-depth analysis, just my thoughts. #19 PR June 2016. #29 PR July 2016. #10 PR August 2016. Newbies Academy Reviewing Classroom, Winner June 2016. First Place The Newbie Academy Review Contest June 2016. Second Place "The Newbie Academy Review Contest " July and Aug 2016. #9 PR Sept 2016.#20 PR Oct 2016. First place "The Newbie Academy Review Contest" November 2016.#22 PR Nov 2016.#36 PR Feb 2017.#67 PR March 2017.#56 PR July 2017.#41 PR Aug 2017. #77 PR Oct 2017. #53 PR Nov 2017. #53 PR Dec 2017.#96 PR Sept 2018. #38 PR Aug 2020.#26 PR Sept 2020. #56 PR Oct 2020. #80 PR Nov 2020.#76 PR Aug 2021. #47 PR Sept 2021. #69 PR June 2023.#53 PR July 2023. #45 PR Nov 2023. #55 PR Aug 2024. #30 PR Sept 2024. #59 PR Oct 2024. #79 PR Nov 2024. #45 PR June 2025.
Printed from https://mathguy.writing.com/main/authors.php/action/reviewers